Sugar is a light gray colt with a light gray muzzle and has a light gray mane and tail with light blue highlights. Cream is her fraternal twin brother and they only appear in "Oh, Baby". Cream and Sugar are the youngest horses at Horseland and have a short mane and tail, only Sugar's is shorter than Cream's. They visit Horseland when their mother was sick and couldn't take care of them. Even though some grown-up horses like Calypso and Aztec are jealous while Scarlet develops her kindness to both these foals.